Dutton Award rarity

[brentsams]

Updated 5-17-2022
1992. 1993

Updated 4-22-2022
1985

Updated 4-11-2022
1997, 1998, 1999

Updated 4-6-2022
1986, 1988, 1990, 1991, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2010.

A rarity occurred in the Dutton Award voting this year with two wrestlers from the same school finishing 1-2 in the voting. Mike Stump asked if this has ever happened before and my research found yes, it has happened twice before. Does anyone know when else if has occurred?...

Without looking at my list below. OK a hint, Has anyone outside the Parkersburg South and Independence fan bases know when else it has happened?

Below is a partial list of Dutton Award Winners, Runner-ups and Honorable Mentions going back to 2011. I will try to complete the list before next wrestling season begins. There is a lot great wrestlers on the list that brings up a lot of memories from back in their day. Feel free to add to the list in this thread.

Thanks - Brent

YEAR Dutton Award Runner-Ups and Honorable Mentions
1985 Dave Miller, Parkersburg South
-RU Larry Childers, St. Marys
-HMs Darren Moore, Parkersburg South; Lester Hughart, St. Marys; Mike Knox, John Marshall; Jim Lamb, West Fairmont.

1986 Mike Lantz, Parkersburg
-RU Rich Greathouse, Spencer
-HMs Rich Cokeley, Harrisville; Mike King, Mullens; Jim Lamb, West Fairmont

1987 Vinnie Monseau, Wheeling Park

1988 John Crain. Oak Glen
-HMs Gary Tuttle, Parkersburg; Tom Giovengo, Bishop Donahue; Sean Biser, Keyser; Todd Kendall, Spencer

1989 Gary Tuttle, Parkersburg

1990 Todd Kendall, Spencer
-RU Doug Rexroad, Parkersburg
-HMs Scott Moore, Pkb South; Ed Neely, Weirton Madonna; Todd Chertow, Huntionigton; Robert Jarrett, Hedgesville; Aaron Fleming, Parkersburg; R.C. Anderson, Cameron; Tom Greathouse, Spencer; Kelly Morris, Braxton County.

1991 Jay Michael, North Marion
-HMs Doug Moore, North Marion; Jon Smith, Huntington; Orarn Butler, St. Marys; Eric Potts, Cameron; R.C. Anderson, Cameron; Jason Barton, Pkb South.

1992 R.C. Anderson, Cameron
- HMs Steve Higgins, Parkersburg; David Fleming, Parkersburg; Doug Moore, North Marion; Mike Mason, Williamstown.

1993 Doug Moore, North Marion and Mike Mason, Williamstown
- HMs N/A

1994 Mark Samples, George Washington

1995 Jason Taylor, Wheeling Park

1996 Jeremy Hart, Independence

1997 Ryan Muldrew, John Marshall
-RU n/a
-HM DeWitt Stanley, Brooke; Jason Johnson, Parkersburg South

1998 Jason Johnson, Parkersburg South
-RU n/a
-HM David Drennen, Wirt County; Adam Gorby, North Marion; Ryan Besedich, North Marion; Denny Lebec, Oak Glen; Chad Pratz, Linsly.

1999 Mike Miller, Wirt County
-RU Nicholas Hedrick, Fairmont Senior
-HM n/a

2000 Anthony Regalbuto, Hedgesville

2001 Matt Stevens, Parkersburg High

2002 Jeff Courtney, Fairmont Senior

2003 Matt Easter, Nitro

2004 Lou Thomas, Parkersburg High
-RU Shane Smith, Williamstown
-HMs Casey Hughes, Cameron; Juston Ashley, Calhoun County

2005 Brandon Rader, Parkersburg High
-RU ?
-HMs Mitch Smith, Ripley; Anthony Easter, Nitro; Dustin Richey, John Marshall; Derrek Scarbro, Shady Spring

2006 Chad Porter, Parkersburg South
-RU Ronnie Green, Wheeling Park
-HM Robert Rash, Independence

2007 Dustin Haislip, Musselman
-RU Andy Thomas, Parkersburg
-HM Anthony Easter, Nitro; and Wesley Byard, North Marion

2008 Seth Easter, Nitro
-RU Andy Thomas, Parkersburg
-HM Anthony Jeffers, Point Pleasant; Nick Hylton, Liberty Raleigh

2009 Mason Bailey, East Fairmont
-RU Cameron Gallaher, Grafton
-HM Dirk Bauer, Wheeling Park; and John King, Philip Barbour

2010 Jordon Nolan, Parkersburg
-RU Josh Fisher, Spencer
-HM Rusty Maness, Point Pleasant; Cody Clark, Calhoun County

2011 Josh Fisher, Roane County
-RU Kyle Bauer, Wheeling Park; and Damen Capper, Berkely Springs
-HM Rusty Maness, Point Pleasant

2012 Dylan Cottrell, Roane County
-RU Elijah Hull, Lewis County
-HM David Jeffrey, Parkersburg South; Adam Bicak, Ripley; Tory Bennett, Berkeley Springs; and Zach Brown, Oak Glen

2013 Justin Arthur, Huntington
-RU Jared Haught, Parkersburg
-HM Jake Smith, George Washington

2014 Dalton George, Williamstown
-RU Terrance Fanning, Preston
-HM Seth Cutright, Buckhannon-Upshur and Bryce Humphreys, Winfield

2015 Logan Grass, Huntington
-RU Bryce Humphreys, Winfield
-HM N/A

2016 Lucas Simpkins, Ripley
-RU Cam Moore, Roane County
-HM Noah Adams, Independence

2017 Noah Adams, Independence
-RU Jacob Hart, Independence
-HM Justin Allman, Parkersburg South and Josh Humphreys, St. Albans

2018 Josh Humphreys, Parkersburg South
-RU Braxton Amos, Parkersburg South
-HM Brock Whorton, East Fairmont

2019 Braxton Amos, Parkersburg South
-RU Peyton Hall, Oak Glen
-HM Zach Frazier, Fairmont Senior

2020 Braxton Amos, Parkersburg South
-RU Peyton Hall, Oak Glen
-HM John Martin Best, Parkersburg

2021 Gavin Quiocho, Parkersburg South
-RU Blake Boyers, East Fairmont
-HM N/A

2022 Derek Raike, Point Pleasant
-RU Justin Bartee, Point Pleasant
-HM Gage Wright, Parkersburg South

[Letsgooo]

Well I guess if your a four timer champ it’s automatic. Only way they could finish 1-2.

Peyton Hall should have won this award once.

[coach_stump]

One would think that there is a complete record of such a prestigious award, not just showing the winner of the Dutton but those who placed 2nd or 3rd. There would be some high quality wrestlers listed for sure

[washed_up1]

brentsams if you google 2008 Seth Easter Dutton Award you can find a news article from Times West Virginia that lists Andy Thomas, Parkersburg, as Runner-up and Anthony Jeffers, Point Pleasant, and Nick Hylton, Liberty Raleigh, in the HM spot. If you google 2010 Dutton Award Jordon Nolan you will find an article from Herald Dispatch that names Josh Fisher, Roane County, as runner-up and Rusty Maness, Point Pleasant, and Cody Clark, Calhoun County, as HM. Tried to add the links on here, but post was denied.

[brentsams]

brentsams if you google 2008 Seth Easter Dutton Award you can find a news article from Times West Virginia that lists Andy Thomas, Parkersburg, as Runner-up and Anthony Jeffers, Point Pleasant, and Nick Hylton, Liberty Raleigh, in the HM spot. If you google 2010 Dutton Award Jordon Nolan you will find an article from Herald Dispatch that names Josh Fisher, Roane County, as runner-up and Rusty Maness, Point Pleasant, and Cody Clark, Calhoun County, as HM. Tried to add the links on here, but post was denied.

Thank You

[brentsams]

updated 4-11-22

[brentsams]

Updated 4-22-2022, 1985 Award

[brentsams]

updated 5/17/2022 - 1992 and 1993 awards